Table of Contents
- 1. How to increase direct bookings for your B&B starts with understanding why guests choose Booking.com, Expedia and other online travel agencies instead of reserving directly with you.
- 2. If your bed and breakfast is attracting guests but you’re paying more OTA commissions than you’d like, the answer may be simpler than you think.
- 2.1. Why Are Guests Booking Through OTAs Instead of Directly?
- 2.2. Your Guests Are Choosing Familiarity, Not Rejecting Your B&B
- 2.3. Give Guests a Good Reason to Book Directly
- 2.4. Walk Through Your Booking Process Like a Guest
- 2.5. Fix One Booking Obstacle Before Changing Everything
- 2.6. Know Whether Your Direct Booking Strategy Is Working
- 2.7. Here Are Your Key Takeaways
- 2.8. In Conclusion
- 3. How to Increase Direct Bookings for Your B&B
- 4. B&B Profit Margin: Why Full Rooms Can Still Leave You Short of Money-148
- 5. B&B Upselling Ideas: Earn More From Every Booking Without Adding Rooms-147
How to increase direct bookings for your B&B starts with understanding why guests choose Booking.com, Expedia and other online travel agencies instead of reserving directly with you.
If your bed and breakfast is attracting guests but you’re paying more OTA commissions than you’d like, the answer may be simpler than you think.
.
Why Are Guests Booking Through OTAs Instead of Directly?
Here’s something that might sound familiar.
A guest discovers your bed and breakfast, loves the photographs, reads the reviews and decides it’s exactly where they want to stay.
Then they book through Booking.com.
You get the reservation, which is good news. But you also pay commission on a guest who might have booked directly.
And you can’t help wondering, “Why didn’t they just book with me?”
The interesting thing is that the guest may not have chosen the OTA because it offered a better room or a lower price.
They may simply have chosen the booking process they trust most.
Hi, I’m Gerry MacPherson. I’ve spent more than 30 years in hospitality, helping accommodation owners improve their businesses, attract more guests and make running their properties a little less stressful.
Today, we’re going to look at why guests choose OTAs, what might be stopping them from booking directly, and one practical way to start changing that.
Because getting more direct bookings doesn’t necessarily mean spending more on advertising.
Sometimes it means making the booking decision easier.
.
Your Guests Are Choosing Familiarity, Not Rejecting Your B&B
Let’s start with something many owners overlook.
Guests don’t always choose the cheapest booking option.
They often choose the one that feels easiest and safest.
Think about the last time you booked something online.
You probably went somewhere familiar.
You knew how the payment process worked, where your confirmation would appear and what to do if something went wrong.
Your guests behave much the same way.
They may love your B&B, prefer independent accommodation and appreciate personal service.
But when it’s time to reserve, they return to a platform they’ve used before.
That doesn’t mean they’re rejecting your property.
It means the booking platform has already earned their confidence.
And here’s something encouraging.
SiteMinder’s Changing Traveller Report 2026 found that 18% of travellers who began researching accommodation through an OTA expected to book directly with the property.
That’s broader accommodation research, not a figure specifically for B&Bs, but it tells us something useful.
Guests don’t always finish booking where they started looking.
So your job isn’t necessarily to compete against Booking.com.
It’s to give guests enough confidence to complete their reservation with you.
Start by making your official website easy to recognise, your contact information easy to find and your booking conditions easy to understand.
Small signs of trust can make a meaningful difference.
.
Give Guests a Good Reason to Book Directly
Now let’s imagine you own a lovely six-room B&B in a coastal town.
Your average room rate is $150 per night.
A couple books a two-night stay through an OTA.
That’s a $300 reservation.
If your commission is 15%, you pay $45.
Now imagine receiving 40 similar reservations in a month.
That’s $1,800 in commission.
Of course, not every one of those guests would have booked directly. OTAs introduce your property to travellers you might never reach otherwise.
And direct bookings have costs too.
But the example shows why understanding your booking mix matters.
Now imagine a guest finds your property on Booking.com.
They visit your website.
The same room costs $150, the conditions appear similar and there’s no obvious advantage to booking directly.
What would you expect them to do?
Many will return to the familiar platform.
So give them a genuine reason to consider booking with you.
Perhaps direct guests receive a complimentary locally produced welcome treat.
Maybe you provide a personal guide to nearby restaurants, walking routes and attractions.
Or perhaps they can discuss room preferences directly with you before arriving.
The benefit doesn’t always need to be a discount.
Sometimes personal attention is more valuable.
Just make sure your offer is genuine, easy to understand and consistent with your OTA agreements and applicable rules.
.
Walk Through Your Booking Process Like a Guest
Here’s where I’d encourage you to spend a little time this week.
Pretend you’ve never heard of your own B&B.
Seriously.
Forget everything you know about the property.
Imagine you’re visiting the area for a weekend and need somewhere comfortable to stay.
Start by searching for accommodation as a guest would.
Find your property on an OTA.
Look at the photographs, descriptions, prices and booking conditions.
Then search for your B&B by name.
Can you find your official website easily?
Does it immediately explain what makes your property worth booking?
Can you check availability and complete a reservation without confusion?
And here’s the important part.
Use your phone.
A booking button might look perfectly clear on your office computer but almost disappear on a mobile screen.
A calendar might work beautifully with a mouse but become awkward when you’re using your thumb.
Or your booking engine might send guests to a completely different-looking website.
That sudden change can make people hesitate.
Now compare your OTA listing with your direct booking process.
Use the same room, dates and number of guests.
Look at the total price, payment requirements, cancellation conditions and number of steps involved.
You might discover that your direct offer is already attractive.
But perhaps the benefits are hidden.
Or the booking process is unnecessarily complicated.
Sometimes the problem isn’t what you’re offering.
It’s how you’re presenting it.
And that brings us to the most useful part of today’s lesson.
.
Fix One Booking Obstacle Before Changing Everything
Here’s a mistake I’d encourage you to avoid.
Don’t immediately redesign your entire website.
Don’t rush into paid advertising.
And don’t remove your property from booking platforms simply because you’re frustrated with commissions.
Start with one obstacle.
Perhaps your booking button is difficult to find.
Maybe your cancellation policy is unclear.
Or perhaps guests don’t understand why booking directly is worthwhile.
Choose the problem most likely to cause hesitation.
Then make one improvement.
For example, our imaginary coastal B&B owner discovers that the website works well but doesn’t mention any direct booking benefits.
So they introduce a complimentary local welcome treat and a personal guide to the area.
They place a short message beside the booking button:
“Book directly with us and enjoy a complimentary local welcome treat and our personal guide to the area.”
It’s simple.
It’s easy to understand.
And it gives guests a reason to consider booking directly.
Will it persuade everyone?
Of course not.
But it creates a clearer choice.
And once the change is made, the owner can measure whether it helps.
That’s a much better approach than changing five things at once and having no idea which one made the difference.
.
Know Whether Your Direct Booking Strategy Is Working
There’s one final piece of the puzzle.
You need to know where your reservations are coming from.
Look at the last three months.
How many bookings came through your website, telephone or email?
How many arrived through Booking.com, Expedia or another OTA?
If you received 100 reservations and 30 were direct, your direct booking share by reservation count would be 30%.
That’s your starting point.
Now you can set a sensible target.
Perhaps you’d like to increase that share to 35% over the next few months.
That’s not a guarantee. It’s a goal you can measure.
And remember to compare booking costs, not just commission percentages.
A direct booking that requires expensive advertising isn’t automatically more profitable.
Your aim is to build a healthier mix of booking sources while keeping more of the revenue you earn.
You can also ask your booking engine provider whether your property is eligible for Google’s free hotel booking links.
These can help eligible accommodation providers display a direct booking option when travellers search on Google.
It’s another possible route to visibility, but the guest still needs a clear, reassuring booking experience.
.
When guests book through an OTA rather than directly with your B&B, what do you think is the biggest reason?
Is it convenience, familiarity, price or something else you’ve noticed?
I’d love to hear about your experience.
Leave your answer in the comments.
.
Here Are Your Key Takeaways
- Familiarity influences booking decisions.
- Trust helps guests book directly.
- Give guests a clear booking benefit.
- Remove one booking obstacle at a time.
- Measure your direct booking progress.
.
In Conclusion
If there’s one thing I’d like you to remember, it’s this.
Guests booking through OTAs doesn’t necessarily mean they’re rejecting your B&B.
Often, they’re choosing a booking process they already understand.
And that’s something you can work on.
Make your direct booking option easy to find, clear to understand and comfortable to use.
Give guests a genuine reason to book with you.
Then measure what happens.
You don’t need to change everything overnight.
Start with one improvement that makes sense for your property.
To help you put today’s lesson into practice, I’ve created a Direct Booking Action Plan, available through our Patreon community. You’ll find the link in the notes.
You can also download Your B&B Starter Blueprint for more practical guidance on building a stronger B&B business.
And if you’d like help avoiding other common business mistakes, join my free webinar, The 5 Biggest Mistakes B&B Owners Make (and How to Fix Them).
Next episode, we’ll talk about Website Optimisation and ask:
Is my website helping guests book, or making them leave?
Because attracting someone to your website is only the beginning.
Helping them feel comfortable enough to make a reservation is the next challenge.
If you’re interested in more resources to help grow your business, visit bedsbreakfastsbusiness.com.
Remember, you don’t need to have everything figured out. You just need to know your next right step.
Thanks for spending some time with me today. Take care of yourself, take care of your guests, and I’ll see you next time on Beds, Breakfast & Business.
Join us for free on Patreon
https://www.patreon.com/cw/BedsBreakfastBusiness
(All weekly downloads can be found on Patreon for members)
.
Check out the recent Free Resource
Gerry MacPherson LinkedIn Profile
LinkedIn — Bed, Breakfast & Business
Facebook — Bed, Breakfast & Business
Instagram — Bed, Breakfast & Business
Gerry MacPherson
Say hi on social …
.
A Division of Keystone Hospitality Property Development

